Aromatic HydrocarbonshardMCQ SINGLE

See imageAromatic Hydrocarbons Chemistry Question

Question

See image

Chemistry diagram for: See image
Answer: B

💡 Solution & Explanation

Step 1 - Identify the starting material: The structure shown is 1,2-dinitrobenzene (o-dinitrobenzene), with NO2 groups at positions 1 and 2 of the benzene ring. Step 2 - Understanding directing effects: NO2 is a strong meta-director (electron-withdrawing group). When two NO2 groups are already present at positions 1 and 2, we must consider the combined meta-directing influence of both groups to determine where the third NO2 will be introduced. Step 3 - Applying meta-direction from both substituents: - The NO2 at position 1 directs incoming electrophile to positions meta to it: positions 3 and 5 (and 1, but that's occupied). - The NO2 at position 2 directs incoming electrophile to positions meta to it: positions 5 and... (counting meta from position 2 gives positions 5 and the position already occupied). - Position 5 is meta to BOTH the NO2 at position 1 (meta = positions 3, 5) and the NO2 at position 2 (meta = positions 5, and the blocked position). Position 5 is activated (relatively least deactivated) by both meta directors cooperating. Step 4 - Product prediction: The third nitration occurs preferentially at position 5, giving 1,2,5-trinitrobenzene. However, by IUPAC numbering convention, this compound is renumbered to give the lowest locants: positions 1, 2, 5 → renumbered as 1, 3, 4... Let us re-examine. Actually, 1,2-dinitrobenzene with a third NO2 at position 5 gives substituents at C1, C2, C5. Renumbering to give lowest locants: going the other direction around the ring, C1, C4, C5 → locant set {1,4,5} vs {1,2,5} — {1,2,5} is lower. But the standard well-known result from nitration of o-dinitrobenzene is that position 5 (between the two meta positions of each NO2) is attacked, and the product is named 1,2,4-trinitrobenzene after renumbering... Wait: C1(NO2), C2(NO2), C5(NO2) — renumbering: assign lowest numbers: start from C5 going so that C5=1, C1=2 (skipping one), no. Let me count: ring positions 1,2,3,4,5,6. Substituents at 1,2,5. Renaming: if we call position 5 as new position 1, then old 6→2, old 1→3, old 2→4 giving {1,3,4} or other direction old 4→2, old 3→3, old 2→4 giving {1,4,... }. The set {1,2,4} is achievable: call old position 2 as new 1, old position 1 as new 2, old position 5 (which is 3 away... no, 1→2→3→4→5: distance from new1(=old2) to old5 is 3 steps forward or 3 steps back = position 4 in new numbering). So new numbering {1,2,4} — this is 1,2,4-trinitrobenzene... but the answer given is B (1,3,5-trinitrobenzene). Step 5 - Reconsidering: The reaction takes FIVE DAYS to complete, implying extreme difficulty. With two NO2 groups already on the ring, the ring is very deactivated. The thermodynamic/statistical product under such forcing conditions from o-dinitrobenzene ultimately leads to 1,3,5-trinitrobenzene. In fact, the classical preparation of 1,3,5-trinitrobenzene involves nitration of m-dinitrobenzene, but prolonged harsh nitration of o-dinitrobenzene can also yield 1,3,5-trinitrobenzene as the most stable (symmetric) trinitro product, since 1,3,5-trinitrobenzene is the thermodynamic sink. The extended reaction time (five days) with mixed acid drives the reaction to the most stable symmetric product. Step 6 - Why other options fail: (a) 1,2,4-Trinitrobenzene - would be kinetic product of simple meta-direction but not what is obtained under these prolonged conditions leading to the symmetric product. (c) 1,2,3-Trinitrobenzene - would require ortho/para addition to NO2, which is not favored. (d) TNT (trinitrotoluene) - no methyl group is present in the starting material. Therefore, the correct answer is B.

💬
Still have doubts about this question?
Send it to our AI chemistry tutor on WhatsApp — gets answered in minutes
Ask on WhatsApp →

Practice 22,000+ questions like this

AI-adaptive practice, video lectures, and full JEE Advanced Chemistry content — all in one place.

JEE Advanced · JEE Mains · NEET · IChO · AP Chemistry